Home/News/Rankings

A former Call of Duty producer said older games were more fun with less skill-based matchmaking

Nov 21, 2026

Former Call of Duty producer Mark Rubin said in a November 13, 2026 post on X that skill-based matchmaking can make casual matches feel repetitive and leave players with little sense of how much they have improved.

A former Call of Duty producer said older games were more fun with less skill-based matchmaking

Rubin’s record in Call of Duty and XDefiant shapes the criticism

Rubin spent a decade at Infinity Ward. He was a producer on Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare and the original Modern Warfare 2, then served as executive producer on Modern Warfare 3 and Ghosts. He later held the same executive producer role on Ubisoft’s XDefiant.

That shooter famously removed skill-based matchmaking to a minimum, meaning player ability was not considered when creating lobbies. The issue has been a long-running complaint among Call of Duty fans, and it has carried into Modern Warfare 4.

Similar opponents can make matches feel the same

Rubin doubled down on his criticism, arguing that constantly facing opponents of similar ability reduces diversity. In the post, he said players keep playing the same kind of game against people who play the same way and have similar skill, even when they are different players. He added that the constant challenge can keep players using the meta instead of diversifying their loadouts.

He framed the argument as his “2 cents” and said players never feel themselves getting better because each match has the same difficulty: as they improve, everyone in their lobbies improves too.

He distinguishes ranked play from public matches

Rubin acknowledged that skill-based matchmaking is ideal for Ranked Play. His objection was aimed at public matches, where he argued players should encounter a wider range of opponents. Generally, he said, there will be some people better than you and some worse, and that variety made older Call of Duty games more fun when skill-based matchmaking was minimal.

In a follow-up post, Rubin said he wanted to reward players differently based on skill. If a lower-skilled player eliminated a better player, he argued, that action should be rewarded more strongly.

Modern Warfare 4 debate continues

Rubin’s comments come as Infinity Ward faces backlash over matchmaking in Modern Warfare 4. There is currently no word on whether the studio will address the issue in a future update.

The controversy has already drawn wider coverage: a Modern Warfare 4 boss responded to backlash after players called the system “miserable,” fans became upset as evidence suggested skill-based matchmaking was in use, and an ex-Call of Duty developer said an Activision explanation contained a “bullsh*t” claim.

Show text

Related Apps

0 Comments
No comment yet.